Indoor hydroponics has been labelled the sustainable farming method of the future, promising higher yields, less water usage, and reduced dependency on pesticides. Yet, the range of crops grown hydroponically remains limited, with leafy greens dominating the landscape. So why hasn’t indoor hydroponics unlocked its full potential to grow a broader variety of crops? Let’s explore the opportunities, challenges and how innovative technology can revolutionise the way we farm.
The Hydroponic Advantage
Indoor Indoor hydroponics offers numerous advantages that enable growers to benefit by increasing sustainability and efficiency of labour due to controlled environments. In turn, this provides a more reliable and stable food supply for both commercial and home growers. Let's delve into some of the benefits:
Environmental Sustainability:
Indoor Hydroponic farming uses up to 90% less water than traditional farming because of water recirculation.
This method also reduces pesticide use and land usage, whilst protecting soil erosion.
Indoor farms in cities can grow crops close to markets, reducing transportation costs and food waste.
Controlled Environments:
Farmers can precisely manage temperature, light, humidity, and nutrients for faster, year-round production, regardless of the weather.
There is a lower risk of contamination compared to open fields as hydroponic systems are enclosed
Hydroponic systems can be used in small spaces, such as urban areas, and can produce more food per square foot than traditional methods.
Hydroponic systems require less labour than traditional farming methods.
Barriers to Widespread Adoption
Despite the numerous advantages indoor hydroponics offer, there are still many growers who don't maximise this solution or if they do, it's only with a select group of crops. So why is this?
Economic Barriers
The upfront investment for hydroponic systems can be steep, making it challenging for small-scale farmers or those growing low-value crops to justify the expense.
Hydroponic systems demand continuous maintenance requirements - such as monitoring nutrient levels or water quality, adding to operational costs.
Indoor hydroponics often relies on artificial lighting and climate control, especially in indoor farms or regions with limited sunlight. The energy costs can be prohibitive, particularly for crops that require long growth cycles or large spaces.
The potential of indoor hydroponics depends significantly on crop purpose. For example, high-value crops that are processed or sold fresh (e.g. local pesticide free basil for for sauces or fresh herbs for retail) can justify the cost of hydroponics. On the other hand, staples like potatoes, broccoli and carrots, often sold at very low prices, struggle to be economically viable for indoor farming.
Knowledge Limitations
Many traditional farmers remain skeptical of indoor hydroponics due to a preference for soil-based farming due to long-standing familiarity with conventional methods. Additionally, debates over whether hydroponic produce qualifies as ‘organic’ can deter adoption. This is due to the addition of nutrients to water in the growing process. Further, despite commercial viability - technical knowledge of how to grow hydroponically isn't widespread enough.
Crop Limitations - technology barrier
Indoor hydroponics excels with popular leafy green crops like lettuce, spinach, and basil, however struggles with:
Root Vegetables (e.g. Carrots, onions, and sweet potatoes): require adaptations to support their growth. Their large root systems require tailored systems, increasing complexity and costs.
Brassicas (e.g. broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage): Space requirements and long growth cycles make these crops less economically viable in hydroponics.
Large-Scale Staples: Grains like wheat and rice are more cost-effective to grow using traditional methods.
The type of crop grown hydroponically varies by region due to infrastructure, energy availability, and market demand. For instance, Europe and USA leads indoor hydroponic production as there is a focus on leafy greens and herbs for urban markets, which are great crops to grow hydroponically. However, Asia is expanding into growing high-demand fruits like strawberries. Where as, North America is increasing adoption for specialty and organic produce.
Market demand must be large enough to justify the use of Indoor hydroponics for specific crops. For example, a recent study published in Agriculture and Human Values highlights the growing demand for urban hydroponic systems to tackle food insecurity while minimising environmental impacts. However, scaling Indoor hydroponics for diverse crop production remains a key challenge. Overall, at present hydroponic growing is seen to complement traditional farming rather than be solely reliant for primary food supply. But due to the numerous benefits of this method - maybe Indoor hydroponics will dominate the agriculture landscape more in years to come.
Changes that will Impact Indoor Hydroponic Demand
The widespread adoption of indoor hydroponics is becoming increasingly viable as a long-term commercial solution. This shift is driven by several contextual factors that are reshaping the agricultural landscape and the global food supply chain. Let's explore the key drivers of this transformation.
Rising Food Prices: As food prices continue to climb globally, indoor hydroponics presents an efficient and sustainable alternative to traditional agriculture. This cost-effective approach becomes particularly appealing as food scarcity and inflation persist.
Shipping and Globalisation Insecurity: Political interest in reducing dependency on international imports and creating self-sufficient food systems further supports the adoption of hydroponics. Indoor hydroponics allows communities to reduce their reliance on imported produce, fostering resilience and enhancing food security. By enabling year-round cultivation closer to consumers, indoor hydroponics also strengthens the connection between growers and their communities.
Net Zero Goals and Sustainability: Governments and businesses are prioritising sustainability initiatives, such as achieving net-zero emissions. Indoor hydroponic farming can align perfectly with these goals when implemented correctly by reducing air miles associated with imported goods and promoting locally grown produce. This sustainable approach adds significant value to hydroponically grown products in a climate-conscious market that prefers local growing.
Technological Advancements:
The rapid evolution of technology is simplifying and enhancing hydroponic farming in several ways:
AI and Automation: Artificial intelligence and automated systems are revolutionising crop monitoring and management, improving efficiency and accessibility for growers at all scales. An example is Rowain's 'Intellefarm' that 'uses AI to grow food from seed to consumption in just 30 days' explored in Vertical Farm Daily
Zero-Substrate Reusable Technology: Innovative solutions, such as our zero-substrate reusable technology, are cutting costs and reducing waste. By eliminating the need for disposable substrates, these advancements represent a significant step forward in sustainable agriculture, especially assisting remote indoor CEA farms with. Our zero-substrate reusable technology not only reduces costs but also enables the growth of diverse range of nutritious crops, for example protein from legumes that can be grown in GyroCups.
New Nutrients and Growing Systems: Breakthroughs in nutrient formulations and growing systems such as 'smart fertilisers' are further boosting productivity. These improvements maximise plant health and growth rates, ensuring consistent quality and higher yields.
Growing in Urban Spaces: Innovative setups like mobile farms in lorries and repurposed spaces within cities are bringing agriculture to the heart of urban areas. A key example explored in Vertical Farm Daily is how VegeSense focuses on education and small-scale farming with distribution of their 'mini-farms'. This not only reduces the environmental impact of transporting food but also caters to the growing demand for fresh, local produce in densely populated regions.
The Future with GyroPlant Technology :
At GyroPlant, we’re developing innovative hydroponic solutions to overcome traditional limitations and expand the range of crops that can be successfully cultivated for indoor hydroponics.
Additionally, GyroPlant’s focus on research and development aligns with findings from the Journal of Cleaner Production, which emphasise the importance of integrating renewable energy and advanced automation to make Indoor hydroponics more sustainable and cost-effective. By addressing economic and technical barriers, we aim to revolutionise how we farm—from leafy greens to root vegetables and beyond.
Conclusion
Indoor hydroponics holds incredible promise for sustainable farming, but its full potential remains untapped due to economic, technical, and cultural barriers. By leveraging innovative technologies like GyroPlant’s and implementing Indoor Hydroponics in the right way with better knowledge, we can unlock the future of farming.
The question isn’t whether indoor hydroponics will revolutionise agriculture for certain applications, but how soon we can make it happen.
Comments